"He has told you, O mortal, what is good; and what does the Lord require
of you but to do justice, to love kindness, and to walk humbly with your God?"
MICAH 6:8 NRSV
Home
Directions
Contact Us
About Our Church    Sermons    Mission and Outreach    Activities    Weddings and Sacred Unions    Reflections    Announcements    Prayer For The Week   
You are viewing a single article.
Sunday, February 26, 2012
Reaching Too High
by Rev. Joyce Antila Phipps
Texts: Genesis 11:1-9; Mark 1: 9-15

About ten years ago I participated in a workshop attempting to bridge the suspicions that Black and Latino communities often have of each other. Having been raised in an era when race was what divided people, I was surprised to hear both groups talk about language. Language, or the lack of communication between the groups, was the dividing line. Each group was totally convinced that the other was plotting against them and because Latinos spoke Spanish did not understand English and vice versa that trust became particularly difficult. But, then, as I thought about it, the comment made sense. I remembered my own parents wanting me to pretend not to hear so that I could communicate what hearing persons were saying because they were convinced that they were the targets of comment.

Music may be a universal language in that music speaks to our emotions, but we need language to communicate our needs, our fears, concerns, and desires. Since the time that the ancient editorial committee put together the Book of Genesis and its story of the Tower of Babel, human beings have struggled to create a method of communication that transcends our inherited divisions of race, religion, even national origin. The proponents of the old Latin Mass argue that its use transcends those kinds of boundaries, making Catholic worship universal; Muslims look to Arabic as a transnational language.

My own parents, who had been raised to be suspicious of the hearing world, went to a World Conference of the Deaf in 1980 and came back thrilled that through sign they could communicate with persons from all parts of the world. And I have to admit that when I went to Indonesia in 2004, I was excited to be able to communicate with the deaf because, with just a few exceptions, we understood each other's signs. Esperanto, move over.

This morning's reading from Genesis presents a world unified by language and a deity threatened by that unity for, as the text says, "this is only the beginning of what they will do." Much of our imagery of the Tower of Babel derives from extra-Biblical sources, including rabbinic commentary on the Scripture and the myths that grew up around Babel. There are several subtexts in this story that are worth examining. The plain of Shinar mentioned in the text was a geographical locale of uncertain boundaries. Some scholars believe that the name is a corruption of an ancient word for two rivers, the valley where the Tigris and Euphrates rivers come together to empty into the Persian Gulf, the site of Sumer, possibly the oldest city in the world, which morphed into Babylon.

Extra-Biblical sources put Nimrod, the great-grandson of Noah through Ham and Cush, as the builder of the tower, due in large part to the description of him in the previous chapter as "a mighty hunter before the Lord" and king of the cities of Babel, Erech, Accad on the plain of Shinar. Erech, the site of major archaeological excavations, yielded a giant ziggurat. Ancient commentators such as Philo of Alexandria (20 BCE-50 CE), known best for his attempts to fuse Greek philosophy and Hebrew exegesis, crediting Nimrod with the Tower construction, interpreted the phrase "before the Lord" as "in the face of the Lord," or in opposition to the Lord. And the end of the story indicates that the Lord thought Nimrod was clearly reaching too high.

The Tower and its construction became a much painted subject in the middle of the sixteenth century, particularly by Flemish painters. The most famous paintings are by Pieter Breugel the Elder (1525/30-1569), who details Nimrod with the architects during the construction of the Tower. During this period, the Tower was used by the Protestant Northern painters as a symbol of the Roman Church attempting to make itself equal to God. Most of the almost 100 extant artistic images of the Tower are the same, a circular ziggurat, much like the ziggurats of the ancient world and obviously Babylonian.

What can we draw from this story, a myth of the origin of languages and a warning against considering oneself equal to the Lord? And what does this story have to do with our Gospel reading from Mark? First, let's look at the incredibly brief description of Jesus' time in the wilderness. We don't have the stones into bread, the ceding of temporal power, or the temptation to show one's power as we have in Matthew's version. Driven into the wilderness by the Spirit, Jesus remains forty days and is tempted by Satan. This event in Jesus' life is recounted by all three Synoptic Gospels indicating some historical basis beyond the symbolism of forty days and Jesus overcoming temptation and the forty years the Israelites wandered in the wilderness succumbing to temptation.

Self examination reveals our basic temptations: greed and power. The rest are progeny of those basic ones. The consumer culture tells us what we need: stuff, stuff, and more stuff. The words of an ancient confession says: Release us from our desires. Power is the other temptation. It's easy to point at Bashar al-Assad in Syria holding onto power through his brutal bombardment of the opposition in Homs than it is to look at our own national need to be the most powerful nation in the world. The drive for power and greed are not mutually exclusive but are deeply interrelated. Power begets possession of people, of things, of space. And greed feeds the necessity for power for without one you cannot satisfy the other.

Greed and power affect each of us personally as well as it affects national economic and social policy. Domestic violence is often an outcome of the desire for power of one person over another in an intimate living situation; it is fed by the fear of losing control of another seen as a possession. We have this incredible need for control over our lives, understandable in that we do not want to be controlled by others. And there's no simple, "Let go and let God" answer. Life is more complicated than that.

What's most interesting about the Babel story to me is the attitude of the Lord faced with the development of a new urban culture, one that made significant advances in human development. Once people shifted from a hunter-gatherer economic system to an agricultural system, they began to live in groups, groups that require agreement and cooperation. Known as the cradle of civilization, Sumerian culture invented the wheel, a system of cooperation called government, writing, and money. We tend to think of globalization as a modern phenomenon; the only difference between us and the ancient world is the size of the trading universe.

The new urban culture brought new challenges. The Genesis text continues with a list of generations through the end of the chapter and then abruptly begins with the Lord telling Abraham to get up and leave Ur, one of the cities of Sumer, and to begin a long and arduous journey to a new land that the Lord has designated for him and his descendants. So Abraham reverts from an urban culture to a pastoral hunter gatherer culture. That urban culture had other deities just as our contemporary culture does. Those deities were various gods, represented by idols; our deities are the idols of money and power. Unlike Abraham, we cannot just pick ourselves up and retreat to the backwoods of some remote area; we need to learn how to live in our culture without losing our bearings. Living in today's world centered on the essential truths of the Gospel is not easy.

It is like facing the wilderness that sometimes inhabits our souls. .Just as Jesus was tempted not only in the wilderness, but continually had to face temptations so do we. During this Lenten season we should try to take some "soul time," confront the wilderness that sometimes inhabits us, and draw back to grapple with the temptations we face to emerge stronger and more able to overcome them.

Let us pray: Enter our hearts, Holy One, so we may feel your truth and life breathing in us. Help us to overcome the temptations of a society interested in only money and power and open us to the centrality of love. Amen.
AT: 02/26/2012 08:30:34 AM   LINK TO THIS ARTICLE
0 Comments:

Post a Comment
Name:

Check here for Anonymous
Email

Website:

 
Please contact me at the phone number and address below
Phone Number

Address:

 
Comment:

 
1 5 8 2 1 1 4
Prove you are human, enter the
number you see into the box below.
  View Sermons by Tag:
Acceptance
Advent
Advent Season
Allegiance to God
Anger
Authority
Bearing Witness
Betrayal
Capacity for Evil
Care of the Dead
Caring
Challenging the Status Quo
Change
Charity
Christmas
Citizenship
Civil Discourse
Civil Rights
Commandments
Commonality
Communication
Communitarian Ideal
Community
Compassion
Consumerism
Courage
Cowardice
Creating Heaven on Earth
Cyber bullying
Daily Bread
Death
Decent Working Conditions
Demons
Despair
Destruction
Discipleship
Diversity
Doubt
Easter
Economic Policy
Epiphany
Equality
Excising Demons
Faith
Fear
Food Pantries
Forgiveness
Genealogy
God's Image
God's Love
Grace
Grammar of Gratitude
Gratitude
Greed
Grief
Healing
Holy Spirit
Homelessness
Honesty
Hope
Humility
Hunger
Hungry
Hypocrites
Inclusion
Inclusive Community
Inclusive Society
Innovation
Integrity
Joy
Justice
Karl Barth
Kingdom of Peace
Language
Lent
Living Faithfully
Living Within Limits
Love
Loving God
Loving Thy Neighbor
Loving Without Boundaries
Maps for our Lives
Martin Luther
Martin Luther King
Martyrdom
Meekness
Mercy
Migration
Miracles
Money
Moral Imagination
Music
National Identity
Occupy Wall Street
Origins
Our Environmental Future
Patience
Peace
Personal Limitations
Personal Renewal
Personal Responsibility
Philanthropy
Philip Berrigan
Poor
Possession
Possibility
Posterity
Power
Prayer
Questions of Faith
Real Help
Real Love
Reconciliation
Redemption
Reformation
Religious Reflection
Remembering Life
Repentance
Resource Distribution
Resourcefulness
Revenge
Righteousness
Riotous Readers
Rumors
Sacrifice
Satan
Search for Meaning
Second Chances
Self-Idolatry
Sexual Orientation
Sharing Resources
Shifting Priorities
Societal Responsibility
Spirit of God
Spiritual Blindness
Spiritual Sight
Stigmatization
Taking Risks
Tax Policy
Temptation
the Samaritan
Theological Thinking
Tolerance
Tough Times
Transformation
Trust
Truth
Understanding
Union Strikes
Vengeance
Violence
Volunteering
Wealth
Wealthy
Well-Off
Wisdom
Women
May 2013
Languages of the spirit
What TO DO Next
Arbitrary Limits
April 2013
The Strays in my life
Assigning Blame
Responses
Recognizing Jesus
March 2013
Tasting Resurrection
Weeping over Jerusalem
Symbol and Reality
Repentance and Reconciliation
Confronted by Evil.
February 2013
Finishing our work
The wilderness of our hearts
Risking the journey
January 2013
Reading Scripture
ONLY THE BEGINNING
Coming to the water
Unexpeted Gifts
December 2012
Listening to Children
A Gift of Love
Making Joyful Noises
Unwelcome Messengers
Learning To Hope
November 2012
Choices, Hard and Easy
October 2012
Sights Unseen
Getting Mad For the Right Reason
Hard Sayings
Family Values
September 2012
More Than Words Can Know
Children, Dreaming
Are There No Limits?
August 2012
In Whose Name
Soul Food
July 2012
More Than Enough
The Taking of Risks
Prophets We Have Known and Hated
The Power of Touch
June 2012
The Edge of Faith
May 2012
What We Risk In Friendship
April 2012
Pruning to Get Blossoms
Fugitive Faith
Life and Breath
Moving Beyond Fear
Opening the Gates
March 2012
Cleaning Out Our Hearts
Questions, Questions!
Uncomfortable Words
Making Sense of It All
February 2012
Reaching Too High
Bodacious Behavior
Faith Healing
Casting Out Demons
January 2012
Raised Up By Others
Where We Don't Want To Go
Moving Beyond Despair
Beyond Epiphany
Seasons of Time
December 2011
Promises and Dreams
The Third Miracle
How Do We Cry Peace?
November 2011
Fantasies Beyond Our Wildest Dreams
Taking Risks
The Beginning of Wisdom
October 2011
Going Against the Grain
Beyond Schmaltz
What We Owe Caesar
Wedding Woes
Destroying Our Inheritance
September 2011
By What Authority: Making Decisions
Wounded Healers
Curable Wounds
August 2011
Thoughts on a Hurricane
Choose with Care
Send Them Away
Being Human
July 2011
Plenty and Want
Honest Trading
Sourdough, Pumpernickel, and More
Finding Good Soil
Paradigm Shifts
June 2011
Punishments and Rewards
Making Disciples
It Happened a Long Time Ago, Right?
Harder Than It Sounds
May 2011
What the Eye Cannot See
The Many Rooms of Faith
Good Shepherds and Bad
Bread Enough to Go Around
There's More to Truth Than Meets the Eye
April 2011
Living as if Easter Mattered
You Can't Have One Without The Other
Unbinding the Dead
Opening Our Eyes
March 2011
Samaritans in Our Midst
Tempting Fables, Tempting Truth
Be Careful What You Pray For
February 2011
Lilies in the Wintertime
Loving Has No Boundaries
Choosing Life
The Right Seasoning
January 2011
Deadly Virtues
Changing Direction
Rise and Go
What Are We Looking For?
Bearing Witness
December 2010
Origins
Preparing for Peace
November 2010
What Are We Hoping For?
Promises, Promises
Living in Tough Times
October 2010
Looking for Truth
Doorkeepers
We Need To Do More Than Walk
Showing Gratitude
Mustard Seeds of Justice
September 2010
What It Takes
Honest Brokers
Mapping the Way
Give Us Our Daily Bread
August 2010
The Shape of the Table
Keeping the Commandments
Standing Within The Fire
Who's on Second?
The Demons That Possess Us
July 2010
Snakes and Stones
Kitchens and Beyond
Help! I Need Somebody - Help!
June 2010
The Demons That Possess Us
The Limits of Power
After
May 2010
The Languages of God
Answering Judas